The Elephant Toenail Knife
"An imposing piece of serious cutlery."
Bernard Levine  Knives 1991

C Platts' Sons Jumbo Swellcenter

The Elephant Toenail is a massive knife with gigantic blades. It has one of the largest master blades ever made for a pocketknife. It was not one you'd simply forget you had in your pocket as you went through the day.

The complete history of this unusual knife is partially a mystery to us today; however, we can conclude that it wasn't a letter opener, a "fruit knife" or a gentleman's "Sunday knife," though limited numbers were made back then with pearl handles. I also doubt it was designed for combat or as a weapon of self-defense. How quickly can you get that master blade open?

One aspect of the toenail we can conclude from old advertisements and catalogs is that it was marketed as having many different uses. It is for this reason we have so many different names for the same pattern.

The Toenail has  been referred to as "Old Honesty," "Camp Knife," "Oyster Shucker," "Pumpkin Seed," "Rope Knife," "Old Faithful," "Jumbo," and "Vest Pocket Axe."

ThomasMFGtoenail

The first time the 6250 pattern was labeled "Elepant Toe Nail", "Sunfish", "Red Eye" and/or "Old English Rope Knife Used On Sailing Vessels" was in Catalog #70 first put out in 1968 by WR Case. All of these descriptions were used for pattern 6250 in that catalog. None of the previous WR Case catalogs had any "nickname" for the 6250 and, interestingly enough, this was the first Case catalog where other patterns were labeled with their nicknames as well.
Anyway, it is not a sheath knife either, though I am aware of a Case Bros. Cutlery Co. Little Valley, NY Pearl (No. 8250) (c.1900-1912) that was originally sold with a suede pouch. Other than that one, they were sold strictly as a naked pocketknife. I can imagine though as expensive as the pearl handled Toenail was back then, we would have wanted it protected in a suede pouch too; for that matter, considering the current value of that particular knife, we'd want it protected it that pouch even more so today!

     
Play Intro Home Acknowledgments Links About Me Website Designed by Z4Designs